Fresh, local seafood is at the heart of dining on Long Beach Island. There’s no shortage of coastal flavor to savor.
Long Beach Island (LBI) is more than its beaches—it’s a culinary destination.
From fresh seafood to cozy cafes and gourmet spots tucked away in quiet corners, the island offers something for every palate. Over the years, we’ve enjoyed not just helping buyers find their dream homes, but also exploring the best restaurants in Long Beach Island ourselves.
Here’s a local’s take on where to eat, what to try, and how to dine like a true LBI insider.
Table of Contents:
HIDDEN GEMS LOVED BY LOCALS
To experience the best restaurants in Long Beach Island like a local, start with these lesser-known favorites—each with its own flavor and charm.
Crêperie de la Mer & French Café
210 N Beach Ave, Beach Haven, NJ
609.709.1119
A quaint and intimate gem in the Beach Haven historic district, this charming French crêperie is perfect for a light breakfast or midday treat. Known for its made-to-order sweet and savory crêpes, fresh pastries, and bold French press coffee, it’s a cozy favorite among locals. Don’t miss the Monte Cristo—stuffed with ham, egg, cheese, and strawberries. Seating is limited, so plan ahead, especially during the summer when they close at 1 PM and are closed on Tuesdays.
Black Eyed Susans Restaurant + Tavern
7908 Long Beach Blvd, Harvey Cedars, NJ
609.494.4990
This elevated yet approachable farm-to-table spot in Harvey Cedars is ideal for date nights or upscale casual dinners. Since 2009, Black Eyed Susans has wowed diners with locally sourced seafood from Viking Village, seasonal produce, and pasture-raised meats. The menu changes often but always impresses—standout dishes include tilefish, crab cakes, and scallops. Add in thoughtfully crafted cocktails and a curated wine list by their in-house sommelier, and you’ve got a must-visit dining experience.
Black Whale Bar & Fish House
100 N Pennsylvania Ave, Beach Haven, NJ
609.492.0025
For laid-back coastal comfort, Black Whale in Beach Haven hits the mark. Always buzzing in the summer, this casual seafood joint doubles as a local watering hole—great for families, groups, or anyone craving solid seafood in a relaxed setting. Start with the raw bar, then dig into favorites like Shrimp & Scallop Santa Cruz, Bacon Wrapped Scallops, or their signature Bread Pudding for dessert.
YEAR-ROUND CLASSICS
Year-round favorites like Azzurri Italian Cucina and Raimondo’s serve up pasta dishes that bring warmth, comfort, and timeless flavor to Long Beach Island dining.
Open in every season, these beloved spots serve up some of the best food in LBI, along with a strong sense of community.
Azzurri Italian Cucina
8001 Long Beach Blvd, Harvey Cedars, NJ 08008
609.479.1014
One of the most polished dining experiences on the island, Azzurri delivers refined Italian cuisine in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Handmade pastas, seafood like bronzini, and fresh, flavorful appetizers make every visit special. Guests rave about the attentive staff, elegant setting, and an energy that feels more “special night out” than boardwalk bites. Expect a dressed-up crowd and a memorable meal from start to finish.
Raimondo’s
1101 Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
609.494.5391
For over 30 years, Raimondo’s has served classic Italian fare with care and consistency. From flounder francaise to scallops over risotto, everything is made to order with fresh, local ingredients. The cozy setting makes it ideal for date nights and family dinners alike. And yes, the Key Lime Pie is just as good as everyone says.
Salt Kitchen & Bar
350 W 8th St, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
609.991.8001
Located in the Hotel LBI, Salt offers an upscale experience rooted in seasonal ingredients and coastal flair. The menu features elegant plates like filet mignon and Viking Village scallops, served in a sleek, modern space with excellent service. Perfect for special occasions or just a luxurious evening on LBI. Reservations recommended.
Delaware Ave. Oyster House
13211 Long Beach Blvd, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
609.492.3352
This tiny but mighty seafood spot is a favorite for those in the know. With daily-changing oyster varieties, fresh catches, and shareable small plates like octopus and fish tacos, Delaware Ave. Oyster House brings bold flavor to a cozy space. Come early or expect a wait—it’s that good.
The Old Causeway Steak & Oyster House
1201 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050
609.488.1327
Just over in Manahawkin, Old Causeway blends steakhouse vibes with seafood soul. The raw bar is a standout, as are their wood-fired steaks, pork chops, and creative cocktails. Live music and a buzzing bar make this a great pick for groups or casual celebrations. And yes, it’s worth the short drive from the island.
STANDOUT SPOTS
These beloved restaurants offer more than great food. They’re rich in history, local flavor, and personality. From famous wings to coastal classics, these are must-tries on Long Beach Island.
Dock & Claw Clam Bar
506 Centre St, Beach Haven, NJ 08005
609.342.0863
Carrying forward a 50-year tradition, Dock & Claw is a laid-back hangout with deep LBI roots. Once known as The Clam Bar, this updated spot keeps the casual, fun energy alive with lobster rolls, Korean wings, and blackened shrimp tacos. It’s definitely one of the best places to eat on LBI.
The Chicken or The Egg
207 N Bay Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
609.492.3695
Affectionately known as “The Chegg,” this all-day eatery is an LBI institution. The menu runs deep—from breakfast omelets to chicken pot pie, but it’s the wings (18 sauces strong) that steal the show. You’ll likely face a wait during peak season, but the friendly vibe and Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream Sandwich make it well worth it.
Tucker’s Tavern
101 S West Ave, Beach Haven, NJ 08008
609.492.2300
A gastropub with coastal flair, Tucker’s Tavern serves up roasted lamb tacos, lump crab cakes, and a stellar raw bar, all alongside a robust craft beer list and bay views. Rebuilt after Superstorm Sandy, it’s a local favorite for its inviting ambiance, live music, and consistently solid food.
Ship Bottom Shellfish
1721 S Long Beach Blvd, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008
609.494.0088
What started as a cozy seafood market is now an LBI landmark. Known for New England clam chowder, jumbo lump crab cakes, and garlic clams, Ship Bottom Shellfish offers a fresh, family-friendly experience. It’s BYOB, and everything is made in-house—from soups to side dishes.
Kubel’s
28 W 7th St, Barnegat Light, NJ 08006
609.494.8592
With nearly a century of history, Kubel’s is as local as it gets. This full-service tavern offers pub classics with seaside flair—think Barnegat Light sea scallops, fish tacos, and a well-poured pint of Guinness. The no-reservations policy keeps it casual, and the bar’s walls tell stories of its colorful past—including the legendary beer-loving dog, Sinbad.
TIPS FOR DINING ON LBI LIKE A LOCAL
Want to skip the long lines and eat like an insider? Here’s how:
-
- Go off-season. Spring and fall offer shorter waits, quieter dining rooms, and better service.
- Reserve early. Popular spots like Raimondo’s and Azzurri fill up fast. Make sure to book ahead.
- Check seasonal hours. Not all restaurants stay open year-round. Confirm hours before you go.
- Choose family-owned. For true local flavor, support longtime favorites like Kubel’s, Raimondo’s, and Delaware Ave. Oyster House.
EAT WELL, LIVE WELL
Dining at the best restaurants on Long Beach Island is part of what makes life here so rewarding. Great food, local charm, and a laid-back lifestyle—it’s all connected.
If you’re ready to make LBI your home, whether seasonally or all year round, we at LBI Properties are here to help. With 40+ years of local expertise, we’ll guide you to the right property and the right investment.
Call David at 609.290.0779 or Michael at 609.290.3680, or send us an email to get started.